Senator Series Shanabans

For those not following on Twitter, I disagree with Brendan Shanahan's rulings today. Carl Hagelin was suspended for three games for his "elbow" on Daniel Alfredsson and Matt Carkner was suspended for one due to his assault on Brian Boyle.

Shanahan's reasoning was that Hagelin “finishes his check with his arms high, recklessly hitting Alfredsson high with his elbow.” Alright, an elbow high is bad.

Shanahan's reasoning was that Carkner "delivers two punches to Boyle's head, the second of which knocks Boyle to the ice. With Boyle down Carkner continues to throw punches, connecting at least five more times with a player who has chosen not to engage in this altercation." Punching a guy in the head is ok, but continuing to punch a turtle is bad.

These rulings display the utter hypocrisy of the NHL today: one unintentional high hit in the flow of play is three times more egregious than two direct punches to the head and five more to undefined locations upon a prone player's body.

Now add to the equation the $2,500 fine Shea Weber received for grabbing Henrik Zetterberg by the helmet and slamming the Swede's head into the glass. Zetterberg and Boyle were fine, Alfredsson did not return to the game. It is clear that Shanahan bases these punishments not on how egregious the action, but by the fallout of said action.

Shanahan's process is flawed and unfair.

Punishing Hagelin based on the fact that Alfredsson was hurt does not take into account the fact that the 39 year old has a long history of injuries. Alfredsson has not played a full season since his rookie year due to a litany of bumps, bruises and breaks. The laundry list of ouchies includes knocks to his hip, ankle, back, knee, head, jaw and "upper body" so it is of little surprise that a little bit of contact took him out yet again. Wolski gave him his first recorded concussion earlier this season and doctors (and Lindroses) have shown that it is easier to get another concussion once a player has already had one - if Alfredsson does indeed have another, which has yet to be diagnosed. Ryan Callahan took an elbow to the head from Chris Phillips in Game 2 but he didn't collapse like a house of cards so the play wasn't even reviewed.

Hagelin is classy and was, of course, apologetic for hitting his childhood hero. If anything, the way Hagelin handled himself will endear him even more into the hearts of Ranger fans. But he did make things worse by apologizing in his meeting with Shanny - as most kids learn, by saying "sorry" you are admitting that you've done something wrong. Hags may think he did something wrong but personally, I don't think he did. He finished a check and, if Alfredsson wasn't the NHL equivalent of Elijah Price, he would have skated off with a two minute minor, at most.

As for Carkner, he received most of the punishment he deserved in the game. The refs gave him the appropriate 2, 5 and 10 and all that should be left is a beating at the hands of a Ranger. It is not his fault that Boyle bitched out. And to suspend Carkner for a game that he likely would have been benched for makes the ruling even more silly - as an Sens fan explained to me, MacLean has alternated Carkner with Gilroy in recent weeks so it was more than likely that Carkner would have been out anyway.

So the Rangers lose an energetic, capable and clean (24 PIM in 64 games) kid for the next three games while Ottawa goes about business as usual in Game 3 without Carkner. By no means has justice been served, in any form. But what it is is what it is, and the series continues tonight. Let's hope that the Rangers can recover from the loss of Game 2 and the loss of Carl Hagelin - it is all that they can do.

 Senator Series Shanabans - A Deep Dive into Playoff Suspensions

Playoff hockey is known for its intensity, physicality, and high stakes. It's a time when players leave everything on the ice to chase the coveted Stanley Cup. However, with the heightened emotions and physicality, comes the increased potential for disciplinary actions. In this article, we'll take a close look at the Senator Series Shanabans, examining notable suspensions, the rationale behind them, and addressing frequently asked questions (FAQs) about player safety and playoff sanctions.

Section 1: The Playoffs' Physicality

The Playoff Atmosphere: Setting the stage by highlighting the unique intensity and physicality of playoff hockey.

The Role of Player Safety: Discussing the importance of player safety in the modern NHL.

Section 2: Notable Suspensions

A comprehensive examination of some of the most notable playoff suspensions handed out during the Senator Series:

Incident Recaps: Describing the incidents that led to suspensions, including hits, slashes, and altercations.

Impact on the Series: Analyzing how these suspensions affected their respective series and the teams involved.

Section 3: The Shanahan Factor

An in-depth look at Brendan Shanahan's role as the NHL's Senior Vice President of Player Safety and his approach to postseason disciplinary actions:

Shanahan's Decisions: Discussing how Shanahan and his team arrive at decisions regarding suspensions, emphasizing transparency and consistency.

Player Accountability: Exploring the concept of player accountability and the responsibility of maintaining a safe and competitive playing environment.

Section 4: Addressing Common Questions (FAQs)

Answering frequently asked questions about suspensions, player safety, and the playoff environment:

Why are suspensions more common in the playoffs?

An examination of the factors contributing to the increase in disciplinary actions during the postseason.

What impact do suspensions have on teams and their playoff aspirations?

Insights into how suspensions can alter the course of a playoff series and their implications for team success.

Are there any recent rule changes or updates aimed at improving player safety in the playoffs?

A discussion of recent rule changes and safety measures implemented to protect players during the postseason.

Section 5: Conclusion

In the heat of playoff battles, emotions run high, and the intensity reaches its peak. However, it's crucial to strike a balance between the passion of the game and player safety. The Senator Series Shanabans remind us that the NHL is committed to upholding its standards and ensuring that players are safe on the ice, regardless of the postseason stakes. While suspensions may temporarily alter the dynamics of a series, they serve as a powerful reminder that the safety of the athletes remains paramount. As fans, we can enjoy the thrilling moments of playoff hockey while knowing that the league is taking steps to protect its most valuable assets - the players themselves.

Odds, Ends And Avery

First off, this is post #700 in Scotty Hockey history so I just want to take a second to say thanks to everyone for their support and their readership. When I started I was getting about a dozen or so hits a day, and now I get four hundred or so a day. You guys rock and I thank you all.

So to start off the special post, let's talk about a special player: Sean Avery. If I have given off the impression that I don't want him back, let me apologize because it is far, far from the reality. This summer I bought an Avery jersey because he left the Rangers with a fantastic legacy - he worked hard, he helped the team win, he cared about the fans and he hated our rivals almost as much as we do. If he can come back and do it again, then let's welcome him with open arms because the current crop of Blueshirts struggle with all of the above.

On another side note, with Alex Rodriguez taking the headlines for juicing, it really brings up an interesting contrast - baseball has steroids, hockey has sloppy seconds. According to Baseball Almanac:

The first positive test will result in a suspension of up to ten days. The second positive test will result in a suspension of thirty days. The third positive test will result in a suspension of sixty days. The fourth positive test will result in a suspension of one full year. Finally, the fifth positive test will result in a penalty at the discretion of the Commissioner of Major League Baseball.

Avery's last game with Dallas was on November 30th (a game which he scored a goal). That means that as of right now, he has missed 29 games over two-and-a-half months. While his official suspension was just six game, in effect he was suspended longer then a baseball player who had been busted three times for performance-enhancing drugs.

Does that make sense to you?

Ok, enough on Aves and other other items:

*There is a fantastic, fantastic article about one writer's day as an assistant coach for the Rangers' ECHL affiliate, the Charlotte Checkers. It is a fun read and many thanks to Kukla's Korner for the heads up.

*Carp saw new lines on offense at practice today. My question is why is Renney so willing to juggle his offense while he sticks with the defensive pairings? Redden and Rozsival are allowed to drag down Girardi and Staal and hinder their development game after game but Scott Gomez gets to try every possible winger to find some sort of chemistry. It just doesn't make sense.

*If you haven't checked lately, The Dark Ranger has really stepped up his game of late and his two 'political' cartoons atop his page are fantastic. I highly recommend heading his way and keeping up with with the darkness.

*There aren't many better ways to stick it to your former employer than the way Brendan Shanahan did last night. Tossed away as too old and too slow, all Shanny did was skate for 12:41 (with 1:16 on the power play and 3:42 shorthanded) and collect a beautiful assist on the game-winning goal. We miss you Shanny, as you can clearly tell. Thanks Glen.

*Ok, maybe I am not done with Avery yet. The incompetent columnist Mark Herrmann, who somehow survived the staff cuts at Newsday despite poorly writing about a sport he clearly has no clue about, made the pitch that the Rangers should go after Ottawa's Chris Neil instead of adding Avery. He incorrectly claims that Neil is on the trading block and Neil, frankly, is nowhere near as good as an agitator as Avery. A better fighter, yes, but he can't come close to getting under opponents' skin the way Avery does.

*And there is no telling how long he will have to be in the AHL, where he will be faced with every AHL idiot looking to make a name for himself, but that hasn't stopped The Manic Ranger from putting the cart before the horse and figuring that we will see the last of Lauri Korpikoski once Avery gets picked off waivers. The sad/scary thing? He is probably right. There is no way that the completely useless Aaron Voros will join Pat Rissmiller in Hartford, because that would show that three of Sather's summer free agent signings were complete failures (even though all six were).

*I will throw a Peepin' Foes together for the Caps later tonight or tomorrow morning but as sad-sounding as it is likely to come out we at least can look forward to seeing Alexander Ovechkin, the most exciting player in the NHL. Even Renney's soulless system can't keep Ovie's star from shining. It should be fun.

Odds, Ends, and Avery: The Sean Avery Story

In the world of professional sports, few athletes have left as indelible a mark on their respective leagues as Sean Avery did during his NHL career. Loved and loathed in equal measure, Avery was a lightning rod for controversy, a master of the agitator's craft, and a player whose impact extended far beyond the ice. In this article, we'll delve into the unique and often polarizing journey of Sean Avery, exploring the highs, lows, and frequently asked questions surrounding his colorful career.

The Early Years

Sean Christopher Avery was born on April 10, 1980, in North York, Ontario, Canada. He was drafted by the Detroit Red Wings in the first round (10th overall) of the 1998 NHL Entry Draft. Avery's early years in the NHL were marked by his willingness to engage in physical play and his growing reputation as a player who wasn't afraid to speak his mind.

"Avery Rule" and Controversy

Avery became a household name, not just for his on-ice skills, but for his penchant for stirring the pot. His most notorious moment came in 2008 during a playoff series between his team at the time, the Dallas Stars, and the Calgary Flames. Avery made headlines by screening Flames' goaltender Miikka Kiprusoff while facing him and waving his hands and stick in front of Kiprusoff's mask. The incident led to the creation of the "Avery Rule," which forbids such actions.

Fashion and Entertainment

Off the ice, Avery was a trailblazer in the world of fashion and entertainment. He interned at Vogue magazine during his NHL career and was known for his impeccable sense of style. His interest in fashion eventually led him to a second career as a model and fashion industry consultant.

Avery's foray into the entertainment industry included appearances on reality TV shows such as "Dancing with the Stars" and "The Celebrity Apprentice." He was also an outspoken advocate for LGBTQ+ rights and became involved in various charitable endeavors.

Multiple Stints with the Rangers

Avery's relationship with the New York Rangers was particularly notable. He joined the team in 2007 and quickly became a fan favorite for his tenacity and ability to get under the skin of opponents. His "Averyesque" antics, both on and off the ice, added a layer of excitement to Rangers games.

During his time with the Rangers, Avery was a key contributor to the team's deep playoff runs in 2008 and 2009. His gritty play and ability to draw penalties made him an invaluable asset. However, his time with the Rangers was also marked by controversy, including a suspension for making inflammatory comments about an ex-girlfriend.

Career Highlights and Legacy

Despite the controversies and his reputation as a pest on the ice, Sean Avery had a respectable NHL career. He played for several teams, including the Red Wings, Kings, Stars, Rangers, and briefly with the Hartford Wolf Pack in the AHL. Avery retired from professional hockey in 2012.

Avery's legacy is a complex one. While some view him as a disruptor who pushed boundaries, others see him as a divisive figure whose antics sometimes overshadowed his skills. However, there's no denying that he left an indelible mark on the game and inspired a new generation of players who aren't afraid to express themselves both on and off the ice.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What was Sean Avery's playing style?

Sean Avery was known for his agitating style of play. He excelled at getting under the skin of opponents, drawing penalties, and creating chaos on the ice.

2. How did the "Avery Rule" come about?

The "Avery Rule" was introduced after Avery's infamous screening incident during a playoff game. It forbids actions like waving hands or sticks in front of a goaltender's face while facing them.

3. What did Sean Avery do after retiring from hockey?

After retiring from hockey, Avery pursued a career in fashion, modeling, and entertainment. He also made appearances on reality TV shows and became an advocate for various causes.

4. What is Sean Avery's legacy in the NHL?

Sean Avery's legacy is a mix of on-ice tenacity, off-ice controversy, and his impact on the fashion and entertainment worlds. He remains a polarizing figure in the hockey community.

5. Did Sean Avery ever return to professional hockey after retiring?

No, Sean Avery did not return to professional hockey after retiring in 2012. He explored various other career paths, including fashion, entertainment, and advocacy.

Sean Avery's career was a rollercoaster ride of controversy, memorable moments, and unexpected twists. Whether you loved him or loathed him, there's no denying that he was one of the most intriguing and talked-about figures in the history of the NHL. While his playing days are over, his legacy lives on as a reminder that hockey, like life, is sometimes at its most captivating when it defies convention and embraces the unexpected.

I Hate You Glen

 I Hate You, Glen: A Controversial Look at Glen Sather's Legacy

Glen Sather is a name that elicits a wide range of emotions among hockey fans, particularly those associated with the New York Rangers. To some, he's a revered figure with a storied history in the NHL, while to others, he represents a period of frustration and disappointment for the Rangers. In this article, we will take a deep dive into Glen Sather's legacy, examining his tenure as the Rangers' general manager, his decisions, and the controversies that have surrounded his time with the franchise.

Glen Sather's Tenure with the New York Rangers

The Early Years

Glen Sather joined the New York Rangers as their President and General Manager in 2000, following a highly successful stint with the Edmonton Oilers. He was hailed as a savior, tasked with bringing the Rangers back to glory after years of mediocrity. During his early years, Sather made some notable acquisitions, including signing Jaromir Jagr, a move that generated excitement among fans.

The Jagr Era

The signing of Jagr was a defining moment during Sather's tenure. Jagr became the face of the Rangers and enjoyed several productive seasons with the team. However, despite individual success, the Rangers struggled to make deep playoff runs during this period, leading to growing frustration among fans.

The Post-Jagr Years

After Jagr's departure, the Rangers went through a period of transition. Sather made significant trades and free-agent signings, attempting to reshape the team's roster. While there were moments of promise, such as a trip to the Eastern Conference Finals in 2012, the Rangers fell short of winning the Stanley Cup.

Controversial Decisions and Criticisms

Long-Term Contracts

One of the criticisms leveled at Sather during his tenure was his penchant for handing out long-term, high-value contracts. Some of these deals, while initially promising, later became burdensome for the team's salary cap structure. Critics argue that these contracts limited the team's flexibility to make necessary roster changes.

Coaching Changes

Sather was known for making frequent coaching changes during his time with the Rangers. While some of these decisions led to short-term success, they also contributed to instability within the organization. Fans and analysts questioned whether consistency behind the bench could have yielded better results.

Playoff Failures

Perhaps the most significant criticism of Sather's tenure was the Rangers' inability to secure a Stanley Cup championship during his leadership. Despite having competitive teams, the Rangers came up short in multiple playoff runs, leaving fans frustrated and disappointed.

Frequently Asked Questions about Glen Sather's Legacy

Did Glen Sather have any successes with the Rangers?

Yes, Glen Sather had some successes during his tenure with the Rangers. He built competitive teams that made several playoff appearances and reached the Eastern Conference Finals in 2012. Additionally, his acquisitions, such as signing Jaromir Jagr, brought excitement and talent to the team.

Why is Glen Sather a controversial figure among Rangers fans?

Glen Sather is a controversial figure among Rangers fans because, despite his efforts, the team failed to win a Stanley Cup during his tenure. His management decisions, coaching changes, and long-term contracts have been subjects of criticism.

What is Glen Sather's overall legacy in the NHL?

Glen Sather's overall legacy in the NHL is complex. He had immense success with the Edmonton Oilers, winning multiple Stanley Cups as both a coach and general manager. However, his legacy with the Rangers is more polarized due to the team's inability to secure a championship.

Glen Sather's legacy with the New York Rangers is a topic that continues to spark debates and discussions among hockey fans. While he had his share of successes and made significant contributions to the franchise, his tenure is also marked by unfulfilled expectations and controversies. Whether one loves or hates Glen Sather, there is no denying the lasting impact he had on the Rangers and the NHL as a whole.

Hey Glen!

Thanks for nothing.

Glen Sather has failed the Ranger franchise yet again, allowing future Hall of Famer Brendan Shanahan to go to New Jersey. Sather's squad, led by his two huge free agent failures, can't score goals and now a guaranteed goal scorer is going to the team's biggest rival.

Can you say EPIC FAIL?

On the other side of the coin, best of luck to Shanny. He gets one more kick at the can before riding off into the sunset. Mark March 30th on your calendar, it is the last time the Devils come to the Garden. We took him to court, weighed his pros and cons and at the end of the day, Ranger fans still have much love for the cagey vet. Hopefully we can give Shanny the warm ovation that he deserves (before kicking the crap out of his team).

 "Hey Glen! Analyzing the Legacy of Glen Sather in New York Rangers History"

Glen Sather, a legendary figure in the hockey world, left an indelible mark on the New York Rangers during his tenure as President and General Manager. From his hiring in 2000 until his retirement in 2015, Sather played a pivotal role in shaping the Rangers' fortunes. In this article, we will delve into the legacy of Glen Sather and examine his impact on the Rangers' franchise.

I. The Arrival of Glen Sather

Glen Sather arrived in New York with a sterling reputation earned during his time with the Edmonton Oilers. As the architect of the Oilers' dynasty in the 1980s, Sather's credentials were unquestionable. Rangers fans were filled with optimism as they welcomed him to Madison Square Garden.

II. The End of the Curse

One of Sather's most significant achievements with the Rangers was ending the team's 54-year championship drought. In the 1993-1994 season, Sather constructed a roster that included legends like Mark Messier, Brian Leetch, and Mike Richter. Under his leadership, the Rangers captured the Stanley Cup, and Sather's name was etched in New York sports history.

III. Player Acquisitions and Trades

Sather was known for his shrewd player acquisitions and trades. He brought in key players such as Jaromir Jagr, Brendan Shanahan, and Marian Gaborik during his tenure. His ability to land star talent significantly improved the team's competitiveness.

IV. Development of Young Talent

While Sather was often associated with big-name acquisitions, he also played a role in the development of young talent within the organization. Players like Henrik Lundqvist, Ryan Callahan, and Derek Stepan emerged as cornerstones of the team under his watchful eye.

V. Managing the Salary Cap Era

The introduction of the salary cap in the NHL presented new challenges for teams. Sather navigated this landscape with skill, ensuring the Rangers remained competitive while adhering to financial constraints. His management of the cap allowed the team to retain key players and make strategic signings.

VI. Legacy and Retirement

Glen Sather's retirement in 2015 marked the end of an era for the Rangers. He stepped down as General Manager but remained as team President. His legacy as an architect of the 1994 championship team and a key figure in the Rangers' modern history was secured.

FAQs about Glen Sather's Legacy

Q1: What was Glen Sather's most significant contribution to the Rangers?

A1: Sather's most significant contribution was undoubtedly ending the Rangers' 54-year championship drought by assembling the 1994 Stanley Cup-winning team.

Q2: How did Sather's tenure impact the Rangers' culture?

A2: Sather instilled a culture of excellence and accountability within the organization. His leadership set the standard for future success.

Q3: Who succeeded Glen Sather as General Manager?

A3: Jeff Gorton succeeded Glen Sather as the Rangers' General Manager, continuing the team's commitment to excellence.

Glen Sather's tenure with the New York Rangers was marked by both triumphs and challenges. He will forever be remembered as the architect of the team that ended a decades-long championship drought and as a key figure in modernizing the Rangers' approach to player acquisitions and development. Sather's legacy lives on, not only in the championship banner hanging from the rafters but also in the hearts of Rangers fans who witnessed his impact on the franchise.

So Long Shanny ...

Wednesday afternoon Larry Brooks reported that Brendan Shanahan has decided to open his options to teams other than the Rangers, since Glen Sather hasn't tendered an offer. Shanahan was proud to wear the Blueshirt and wanted to keep it on so he showed incredible patience and it simply didn't pay off. Hopefully it will pay off for him as he has one less month of wear and tear to start the season. I've looked at the pros and cons of re-signing him, I've sent him to court, I suggested he be player/coach ... I guess there is nothing left to do but wish him the best wherever he ends up.

With New York out of the picture, Puck Daddy and I share the same hope that Shanny returns to Detroit. I can't speak to Wysh's wishes but I want him to head to the Wings for several reasons:

1 - The Detroit fans appreciate Shanny as much as we did in New York and a classy veteran such as himself should be properly revered.

2 - The Red Wings are almost assured a playoff spot and are a likely contender for the Cup. It would be great to see Shanny get a chance to go out on top.

3 - Another Stanley Cup with the Wings may just be enough to get his #14 raised to the rafters of the Joe. The Hall of Fame is waiting for him but he has bounced around too much to cement a legacy with any one franchise. A fourth Cup in Motown could certainly help that cause. Few players in the history of hockey have had as much of an impact as Shanahan (he did help rewrite the rules to revive the game after the lockout) and most every one of them has had their numbers go up - Plante, Orr, Mikita, Howe, Gretzky, et. al.

4 - What could make the Winter Classic more special than having two of the game's elder statesmen in Shanny and Chelios out on the Wrigley Field ice having fun like they're kids again?

5 - And could you imagine Shanny skating on the Garden ice one last time ... in the Stanley Cup Finals?

Hey, a man can dream.

Hopefully Shanny's dream of playing in the NHL keeps coming true and he ends up on his feet, even if it isn't in New York or the Motor City. Best wishes Brendan and good luck ...

 "So Long Shanny: Brendan Shanahan's Impact on Hockey and Beyond"

In the world of hockey, few names resonate as deeply as Brendan Shanahan's. Known for his exceptional skills on the ice and his passion for the game, Shanahan has made a lasting impact on the sport both as a player and as an influential figure off the rink. As we bid farewell to a legendary career, this article explores Brendan Shanahan's remarkable journey, his contributions to hockey, and the legacy he leaves behind.

The Early Years

The Makings of a Star

Brendan Shanahan was born on January 23, 1969, in Mimico, Ontario, Canada. His early years were marked by a love for hockey, and he displayed exceptional talent from a young age. Shanahan's dedication to the game, combined with his natural ability, set him on a path to stardom.

Junior Hockey Success

Shanahan's journey to the NHL began in junior hockey, where he played for the London Knights of the Ontario Hockey League (OHL). He quickly established himself as a scoring sensation, showcasing his scoring touch and physical play—a combination that would become his trademark in the NHL.

The NHL Career

A Prolific Scorer

Shanahan made his NHL debut with the New Jersey Devils in the 1987-88 season. Throughout his career, he played for several teams, including the St. Louis Blues, Hartford Whalers, Detroit Red Wings, and New York Rangers. His scoring prowess earned him accolades, including eight 30-plus goal seasons and three 40-plus goal seasons.

The Physical Presence

One of Shanahan's defining attributes was his physicality. He was not only a skilled goal scorer but also a player who wasn't afraid to engage in the physical aspects of the game. His ability to contribute offensively while maintaining a physical presence made him a formidable force on the ice.

Championships and Leadership

Shanahan's time with the Detroit Red Wings was particularly fruitful. He won three Stanley Cup championships (1997, 1998, 2002) with the Red Wings, solidifying his reputation as a clutch performer. His leadership on and off the ice was instrumental in Detroit's success during that era.

Beyond the Ice

The Ambassador

Shanahan's influence on the game extended beyond his playing career. He was a prominent figure in the NHL Players' Association and played a key role in labor negotiations, helping to establish better conditions for players. His ability to bridge the gap between players and management was a testament to his leadership qualities.

A Visionary Leader

In 2009, Brendan Shanahan retired as a player and transitioned into a front-office role with the NHL. He was appointed the NHL's Vice President of Hockey and Business Development and later became the Senior Vice President of Player Safety and Hockey Operations. In this role, he was responsible for player discipline and rule enforcement, helping to make the game safer.

The Shanaplan

Shanahan's most significant off-ice impact came as the President and Alternate Governor of the Toronto Maple Leafs. Under his leadership, the team embarked on a comprehensive rebuild known as the "Shanaplan." This involved drafting and developing young talent, emphasizing analytics, and creating a new culture within the organization.

Legacy and Impact

A Hall of Famer

In 2013, Brendan Shanahan was inducted into the Hockey Hall of Fame, solidifying his place among the sport's all-time greats. His Hall of Fame induction recognized not only his exceptional playing career but also his contributions to the game's growth and development.

Changing the Game

Shanahan's work in player safety and rule enforcement significantly impacted the NHL. He implemented new rules and policies to reduce dangerous plays and protect players. His efforts contributed to a safer and more controlled style of play.

The Shanaplan's Success

While Shanahan's tenure with the Toronto Maple Leafs had its ups and downs, the "Shanaplan" ultimately bore fruit. The Leafs became a playoff contender, and the team's prospects and young talent flourished, offering hope to a passionate fan base.

FAQs About Brendan Shanahan

1. How many Stanley Cups did Brendan Shanahan win as a player?

Brendan Shanahan won three Stanley Cup championships during his playing career. He achieved this feat with the Detroit Red Wings in the years 1997, 1998, and 2002.

2. What was the "Shanaplan" in Toronto Maple Leafs' history?

The "Shanaplan" was a comprehensive rebuild strategy initiated by Brendan Shanahan during his tenure as the President of the Toronto Maple Leafs. It involved drafting and developing young talent, emphasizing analytics, and creating a new culture within the organization to build a competitive team.

3. What was Brendan Shanahan's role in the NHL's Player Safety Department?

As the Senior Vice President of Player Safety and Hockey Operations for the NHL, Brendan Shanahan was responsible for player discipline and rule enforcement. He implemented measures to improve player safety and reduce dangerous plays in the game.

4. Is Brendan Shanahan still involved in the NHL?

As of my last knowledge update in September 2021, Brendan Shanahan remained actively involved in the NHL in his role as the President and Alternate Governor of the Toronto Maple Leafs. However, please verify his current status as it may have changed since then.

5. How did Brendan Shanahan impact the NHL Players' Association?

Brendan Shanahan played a prominent role in the NHL Players' Association, where he was involved in labor negotiations and efforts to improve conditions for players. His ability to bridge the gap between players and management was instrumental in achieving better agreements.

Brendan Shanahan's departure from the world of professional hockey marks the end of an era for a player and leader who left an indelible mark on the sport. From his prolific goal-scoring career to his pioneering work in player safety and his transformative leadership with the Toronto Maple Leafs, Shanahan's impact resonates far beyond the rink. He will be remembered as a Hall of Famer, a visionary leader, and a driving force behind positive change in the game of hockey. As fans bid farewell, Shanahan's legacy endures, reminding us that the love for the game and the commitment to its betterment can shape a lasting and impactful career. So long, Shanny, and thank you for everything.

The Battle Over Brendan

Now Sam over at Rangers Report has been staying on top of the Brendan Shanahan situation and giving update after update but the bottom line is that a day before the season starts, we still don't know what the future holds for a certain Brendan Shanahan. When I was a kid, for big decisions my mom always said that I should write down the two options, and then scribble the pros and cons of each one. It was an easy device to analytically choose which way to go. So which way should the Rangers go with Shanny? Let's take a look at the pros and cons of each situation:

Brendan Shanahan Is Re-Signed

Pros:
*Adds 20 years of experience and three Stanley Cups to the locker room.
*Capable of playing in all situations.
*Will give everything he has every shift he takes.
*Almost certain to score 20 goals through his wicked shot on the power play.
*Handles media pressure well and will take some of the 'bullets' headed towards Drury.
*Even though the results of the Trial were inconclusive, the Garden faithful will certainly give Shanny a warm reception (and keep buying Shanahan merchandise).

Cons:
*Has slowed down in his advanced age.
*Getting more susceptible to injury.
*Will likely take a while to get into game shape after missing preseason.
*Missed Europe, which the team has already said was a tremendous bonding experience.
*Takes a roster spot from a player with potential.
*Could limit the development of the current younger leaders by taking the media pressure unto himself.

Brendan Shanahan Is NOT Re-Signed

Pros:
*Less jockeying to be done to get the team under the salary cap.
*Captain Drury is forced to speak up to the media, something Jagr didn't have to do with Shanny around, leading to more accountability.
*More movement on the power play as Shanny won't be there just sitting in the circle waiting to unleash his predictable one-timer.
*Don't have to worry about changing team chemistry at this point.
*Younger players have less competition for ice time - is Petr Prucha a NHL-level player?

Cons:
*Is Petr Prucha a NHL-level player? I'm not so sure.
*Fan backlash after Sather led Shanny on for so long.
*After seeing them during the preseason, who will score for the Rangers?
*If Drury doesn't step up and take responsibility in the media, the papers will likely hammer the team hard the first instant things go south.
*Shanahan signs somewhere else (Jersey) where he can come back and make the Rangers regret not signing him.

Final Answer?:
To be honest? I just don't know. Going over this list, I think that the right decision is to not re-sign Shanny. Frankly, I think that call sucks but the home opener is on Friday and you should dance with the date you brought, you know? The NHL doesn't have player/coaches anymore and that would be a perfect role for him to step into, especially on a team in transition like the Rangers. I am a big fan of his and would hate, hate to see him become a Devil or - even worse - outright retire. The man has done so much in his career and has done so much for the sport of hockey that he deserves a farewell tour. Let's hope he gets one ...

 "The Battle Over Brendan: A Hockey Legend's Legacy"

The Battle Over Brendan is a captivating story that revolves around one of the most revered and contentious figures in the world of hockey, Brendan Shanahan. His journey from a young, promising player to a revered Hall of Famer is one marked by talent, determination, and controversy. In this article, we will explore the life and career of Brendan Shanahan, the controversies that have surrounded him, and the enduring legacy of this hockey legend. Additionally, we will answer frequently asked questions (FAQs) to provide a comprehensive understanding of the battle over Brendan.

Brendan Shanahan: A Hockey Icon

Early Beginnings

Brendan Shanahan was born on January 23, 1969, in Mimico, Ontario, Canada. From an early age, it was evident that he possessed a rare combination of skill, physicality, and hockey IQ that would set him on the path to stardom.

NHL Debut

Shanahan was drafted by the New Jersey Devils as the second overall pick in the 1987 NHL Entry Draft. He made his NHL debut in the 1987-88 season and quickly established himself as a force to be reckoned with on the ice.

A Prolific Scorer

Throughout his career, Brendan Shanahan was known for his scoring ability. He consistently put up impressive numbers, surpassing the 50-goal mark twice and tallying over 600 goals in his career.

The Controversies

The "Shanahan Summit"

One of the most significant controversies in Shanahan's career was the "Shanahan Summit" in 1992. At a league-wide meeting, Shanahan was one of the players who openly criticized the NHL's then-president, John Ziegler, for the league's lack of discipline regarding on-ice violence.

Elbowing Incident

Shanahan's on-ice aggression occasionally led to controversial incidents, including a notorious elbowing incident involving Brian Moore in 1993. The incident resulted in a lengthy suspension and further fueled debates about his playing style.

High-Sticking Controversy

In the 1997-98 season, Shanahan was suspended for high-sticking Bob Boughner. While some believed the suspension was justified, others saw it as an example of the league being overly punitive.

The Legacy of Brendan Shanahan

Leadership and Character

Despite the controversies that surrounded him, Shanahan was widely respected for his leadership qualities and character. He served as captain for multiple teams during his career and was known for his ability to motivate and inspire teammates.

Hall of Fame Induction

Brendan Shanahan's impressive career was recognized when he was inducted into the Hockey Hall of Fame in 2013. His induction acknowledged his contributions to the sport and his place among the all-time greats.

Off the Ice

Shanahan's impact extended beyond the rink. After retiring as a player, he took on roles in the NHL's Department of Player Safety and later as the president of the Toronto Maple Leafs, where he played a crucial role in shaping the franchise's future.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. What made Brendan Shanahan such a prolific goal scorer?

Brendan Shanahan's goal-scoring prowess was a result of his combination of size, skill, and a powerful shot. He had an excellent ability to find open spaces in the offensive zone and capitalize on scoring opportunities.

2. How did Shanahan's leadership style impact his teams?

Shanahan was known for his lead-by-example approach. His work ethic, determination, and willingness to do whatever it took to win were contagious, inspiring his teammates to elevate their performance.

3. What is the Department of Player Safety, and what role did Shanahan play in it?

The Department of Player Safety is responsible for reviewing on-ice incidents and administering disciplinary actions, such as suspensions or fines. Brendan Shanahan served as the head of this department, where he played a pivotal role in maintaining player safety and ensuring fair play.

4. What is Brendan Shanahan's legacy in the NHL?

Brendan Shanahan's legacy in the NHL is multifaceted. He is remembered as a prolific goal scorer, a respected leader, and a key figure in shaping the league's approach to player safety and discipline.

5. What lessons can be learned from Brendan Shanahan's career and controversies?

Brendan Shanahan's career teaches us that even the most talented individuals can face controversies and challenges. It also highlights the importance of leadership, resilience, and the ability to make positive contributions to the sport both on and off the ice.

The Battle Over Brendan encapsulates the complexity of Brendan Shanahan's life and career in the world of hockey. While he faced controversies and debates, his legacy remains one of excellence, leadership, and dedication to the sport. As a Hall of Famer, he continues to inspire the next generation of hockey players and enthusiasts, leaving an indelible mark on the game he loves. Brendan Shanahan's story serves as a reminder that the world of sports is not just about wins and losses but also about character, leadership, and the enduring impact of individuals who shape the sport's history.

The Trial Of Brendan Shanahan

Hear ye, hear ye, will the First District Night Court of the Blogosphere please come to order!

The Honourable Harry T. Stone presiding.

Today we will hear the case of Brendan Shanahan v. New York Rangers. Mr. Shanahan will be represented by Mr. Scotty Hockey, while the Rangers will be defended by Mr. Glen Sather. The jury of New York Ranger fans will hear each of your arguments and decide the outcome of this case. Opening statements please.

Scotty Hockey: Ladies and gentlemen, I believe that my client, Mr. Shanahan has been disrespected by the defendant New York Rangers and seek to prove that, beyond the shadow of a doubt, they need to tender him a contract. Thank you.

Glen Sather: I feel that we, as an organization, have done nothing wrong, have no need to offer up a deal and will not do anything of the sort.

Judge: Alright gentlemen, I will begin hearing your arguments. The floor is yours Mr. Hockey.

SH: Thank you. I would like to submit into evidence Prosecutor's Item #1, the NHL Official Stats and Media Guide. Within it you will find the details of my clients famed NHL career. Take a listen to these numbers: 20 seasons played, three Stanley Cups won, 1471 points in 1667 games, including 120 in 160 for the defendants. And he got those while battling back from several major injuries that would have injured lesser players' careers.

GS: Your Honour, those numbers reflect the past, while we are an organization looking towards the future. Mr. Shanahan is 39 years old, there is no way he can duplicate those numbers now.

SH: I am just trying to present my client's history to show how much he has contributed in the past and the veteran leadership he can still provide.

Judge: I'll allow it. Want to see a magic trick?

GS: No, no I don't.

Judge: Yeah, I guess you see a disappearing act every day with all of that money you waste. Zing!

GS: Not funny your honour.

SH: [snickers] If it may please the court, I would like to summon a witness. Will Mr. Donald Brashear please take the stand ... Mr. Brashear, do you like the Rangers?

Donald Brashear: No.

SH: On the night of December 30th, 2006, what were you doing?

DB: Playing the Rangers.

SH: We knew that, I meant what were you doing during that game.

DB: The usual - hitting people, slashing, spearing, starting scrums after whistles. It's what I do.

SH: And what happened when my client, Mr. Shanahan, confronted you over your actions?

DB: He beat me up.

SH: Excuse me? Did you say that a 37 year old man beat you up?

DB: I'm not proud of it.

SH: Did you stop taking those aforementioned liberties? The hitting, slashing, spearing ...

DB: Yes.

GS: Your honour, if I may cross examine ... Mr. Brashear, the next time your played the Rangers, and every time since, did you continue to act the fool? I mean, did you continue to cause disarray on the ice by attacking skill players and starting confrontations?

DB: Of course, if I didn't, I wouldn't still be in NHL.

GS: I rest. If I may call my witness, Ms. Cindy Crosby to the stand? Ms. Crosby, when your Penguins beat the Rangers in five games last season, where was Mr. Shanahan?

Cindy Crosby: I don't know.

GS: She doesn't know. She DOESN'T KNOW! That is because Mr. Shanahan was invisible on the ice!!!

SH: Objection! Many of the Rangers were invisible in that series!

Judge: Sustained, prosecutor just present your case, don't make outrageous claims.

GS: Sorry your honour. I would now like to call Markus Naslund to the stand. Mr. Naslund, welcome to New York. Do you feel that you can still make an impact in the NHL?

Markus Naslund: I do. As you can see in that record book, I have played 14 seasons in the NHL and scored 823 points. I just got tired of Vancouver so I stopped playing as well.

GS: I find that hard to believe, as the captain of that team ...

MN: Hey, it's tough when your are the only scorer and opposing teams key in on you.

SH: If I may cross your honour? Mr. Naslund, you said you were the only scorer? Did you not play at times along the immensely talented Sedin twins?

MN: Well, yes but ...

SH: That is all, you may step down. Your Honour and members of the jury, Mr. Naslund scored 194 points over the last three seasons, had a plus/minus of -23 while playing in 245 regular season games. He also played in 12 playoff games and had just five points. My client, however, played in 222 games, had 189 points, was a plus +29 and did it while playing alongside several players less talented than the Sedins - Dawes, Callahan, Drury, Prucha ...

GS: But Naslund is younger and faster.

SH: And has never won a damn thing! Not to mention younger is meaningless when you signed the guy for just two years ...

Judge: [hanging gavel] Stop your bickering. You sound like Dan and Ms. Sullivan. Bailiff Bull, can you step in and separate these two? Geez. Once you two calm down you can offer up your closing arguments.

GS: It's my team and I can do whatever I want. Piss on old time hockey and piss on Shanahan. We don't need him, we have Mr. Naslund now. So suck on that Scotty.

SH: Ladies and gentlemen, the Detroit Red Wings won the Stanley Cup this year and on their roster was a certain Chris Chelios. Chelios, an elder statesman who had already won two Cups, didn't play every game and scored just 12 points. But he was there when his team needed him and he provided the guidance needed to get that team to the promised land. This isn't an either/or thing with Mr. Shanahan and Mr. Naslund. We are stuck with Mr. Naslund after the drunken spending spree of Mr. Sather this summer so he will get plenty of minutes on the ice. But his presence doesn't render Mr. Shanahan useless. He wants to play in New York and he will do it at a discount.

GS: Bah, I already picked up Patrick Rissmiller and Dan Fritsche to fill out the roster and be useless grinders! I don't need Shanahan!!!!

Judge: Mr. Sather!! You already closed! Another word and I will hold you in contempt of court!

GS: [stamps feet, chomps on cigar]

Judge: I thought so. So I leave it to you, Ranger fans of the jury, to deliberate and determine a verdict. Place it in the comments and we will determine the sentence at a later date.

[Gavel]

 "The Trial of Brendan Shanahan: The Man Behind NHL Player Safety"

In the high-octane world of professional ice hockey, where hits, checks, and altercations are part of the game, there exists a unique and often scrutinized role—the enforcer of player safety. Brendan Shanahan, a name synonymous with both finesse and physicality on the ice during his playing career, took on the responsibility of overseeing player safety in the NHL. In this article, we delve into the fascinating world of the NHL's Department of Player Safety, led by Brendan Shanahan, explore the intricacies of player discipline, and address some frequently asked questions (FAQs) about this crucial aspect of the game.

Part 1: Brendan Shanahan - From Player to Disciplinarian

1. A Storied Playing Career

Before he donned the suit and tie, Brendan Shanahan was a star player in the NHL. Known for his scoring ability and physical play, Shanahan enjoyed a Hall of Fame career that left an indelible mark on the game.

2. Transition to Player Safety

In 2011, Shanahan took on a new role as the head of the NHL's Department of Player Safety. His unique perspective as a former player made him an ideal candidate for the job.

Part 2: The NHL's Department of Player Safety

3. The Role and Responsibilities

The Department of Player Safety is tasked with reviewing plays that may result in supplementary discipline, such as fines or suspensions. Their goal is to maintain player safety while preserving the integrity of the game.

4. Video Reviews and Decision-Making

One of the key tools of the department is video review. Each incident is carefully examined to determine if it warrants disciplinary action.

Part 3: Controversial Decisions and Criticism

5. The Gray Areas

Player discipline in the NHL often involves judgment calls, and as a result, decisions can be controversial. Fans, players, and analysts may disagree with rulings, leading to debates and discussions.

6. The Shanaban Era

During Brendan Shanahan's tenure, the term "Shanaban" became synonymous with suspensions. His video explanations of decisions became must-watch content for hockey fans.

Part 4: The Legacy of Brendan Shanahan

7. The Impact of Shanahan's Leadership

Brendan Shanahan's leadership of the Department of Player Safety has left a lasting legacy. The department's work has contributed to safer play and reduced dangerous incidents on the ice.

8. Player Safety Initiatives

Under Shanahan's guidance, the NHL introduced various player safety initiatives, including Rule 48 (head hits) and Rule 41 (boarding), aimed at reducing high-risk plays.

Part 5: FAQs (Frequently Asked Questions)

1. How are decisions made in the Department of Player Safety?

Decisions are made after careful review of video evidence and consultation among department officials. The goal is to ensure consistency and fairness in rulings.

2. Why are some suspensions longer than others for similar incidents?

Suspension lengths can vary based on several factors, including the severity of the infraction, the player's history of discipline, and the impact on the injured player.

3. How has player safety improved in the NHL under Brendan Shanahan's leadership?

The NHL has made strides in reducing dangerous plays and head injuries through rule changes and stricter enforcement. Player safety is a top priority for the league.

4. What is the future of player safety in the NHL?

Player safety will continue to evolve as the NHL seeks to minimize injury risks. Technology and data analysis will likely play a larger role in identifying and preventing dangerous plays.

Brendan Shanahan's transition from a hard-hitting player to the guardian of player safety in the NHL is a testament to the league's commitment to the well-being of its athletes. The Department of Player Safety, under Shanahan's leadership, has made significant strides in creating a safer on-ice environment while preserving the essence of the game.

While player discipline decisions may remain a topic of debate, it's clear that the NHL's commitment to player safety is unwavering. Brendan Shanahan's legacy extends beyond his playing days, and his contributions to the sport will continue to shape the future of ice hockey, ensuring that players can showcase their skills and passion for the game while being safeguarded from unnecessary risks.