Bring Back The Brawler!

Larry Brooks mentioned in his Sunday column that:

"The Rangers, by the way, have made no effort to re-sign Colton Orr, who will have no trouble at all scoring a multi-year deal within hours of the opening of the market. We're told Florida is keenly interested in the heavyweight."

Orr simply has to be re-signed by the Rangers. Sure John Tortorella doesn't care for fourth lines, doesn't care for fighters and wants to make the team faster. It doesn't matter: Tortorella and the Rangers need Colton Orr.

It is no coincidence that the first time that Colton Orr was scratched all season long was the only one where a Ranger was seriously injured. As I said back then, had Orr remained in the lineup Donald Brashear would have had someone to worry about on the ice. Instead he had free reign to hit whomever he liked and he did, costing the Rangers their top defensive forward and penalty killer Blair Betts.

Colt missed eight games in '07-08 and the enforcer role had to be passed around; the results weren't pretty. Remember Brandan Shanahan wrestling Steve Ott? Or Dubi holding on for dear life against Mike Komisarek? Horrifying.

Orr made $550k last season with a cap hit just under that. Aaron Voros made $1.2m with a cap hit of a cool mill - exactly what it will be the next two seasons. Waive him, send him to the minors and offer Orr that much money and the tough guy should stick around. Sather was willing to realize his mistake with Fritsche and Rissmiller, it is time he finished cutting ties with the triumverate of mediocrity.

Voros proved that not only can't he skate/stickhandle/score/pass/check but he can't fight either. Dane Byers and Justin Soryal both may be able to take care of themselves but they are both kids. Byers has the tools to be a power forward and shouldn't destroy his hands fighting every Flyer, Islander and Devil goon. Soryal might be able to turn into a major league tough guy but he has to get more experience and take his damned visor off first. No matter their youthful exuberance and willingness to throw down the mitts, neither one can step into the skates of a tough guy like Orr.

Orrsie is a top-five NHL heavyweight and in the seemingly never-ending grind of the regular season, having a player like that is invaluable in keeping the skill players safe and the fans interested. Sather shouldn't let him get away.

 "Bring Back The Brawler: The Role of Enforcers in Hockey"

Hockey is a sport known for its speed, skill, and physicality. While skillful plays and spectacular goals often take center stage, there has always been a place in the game for players who excel in a different aspect: the enforcers. These rugged and fearless individuals are known for their willingness to drop the gloves and protect their teammates, making them an integral part of hockey history. In this article, we'll explore the role of enforcers in hockey, the evolution of their role, and the debate surrounding whether it's time to bring back the brawler.

Section 1: The Enforcer's Historical Role

1.1. The Birth of Enforcers

Explain how the concept of enforcers emerged in hockey, dating back to the early days of the sport.

1.2. Intimidation and Deterrence

Discuss how enforcers have traditionally served as a deterrent to dirty plays and provided a sense of security for skill players.

Section 2: The Changing Landscape

2.1. Rule Changes

Explore how rule changes, such as stricter penalties for fighting, have affected the role of enforcers in the modern game.

2.2. Emphasis on Speed and Skill

Discuss the shift in focus towards speed and skill in the NHL and its impact on the demand for enforcers.

2.3. Safety Concerns

Acknowledge the increasing concern for player safety and the long-term consequences of fighting.

Section 3: Arguments for Bringing Back the Brawler

3.1. Protecting Skill Players

Argue that enforcers can still play a vital role in protecting skill players from dangerous hits and cheap shots.

3.2. Maintaining Accountability

Highlight the idea that having enforcers on the ice can hold players accountable for their actions.

3.3. Providing Entertainment

Acknowledge the entertainment value that fights bring to the game and how they can energize both players and fans.

Section 4: Arguments Against Bringing Back the Brawler

4.1. Declining Relevance

Discuss how enforcers have become less relevant in a game that prioritizes speed and skill.

4.2. Safety and Health Concerns

Address the growing concern about player safety and the potential risks associated with fighting.

4.3. Evolution of Hockey Culture

Explore how the culture of hockey has shifted towards a more inclusive and sportsmanlike approach.

FAQs

1. Can enforcers coexist with the modern style of play?

Explain that while enforcers can adapt to the modern game, their role may be limited compared to the past.

2. Are there any current players who embody the enforcer role?

Mention a few players who still embrace the enforcer role but emphasize their rarity.

3. How can the NHL balance player safety and the desire for physicality?

Suggest that the NHL can achieve a balance through stricter penalties for dangerous plays and a continued emphasis on player safety.

The debate over whether to bring back the brawler in hockey remains a contentious one. While some argue that enforcers play a crucial role in protecting skill players and maintaining accountability, others believe that the game has evolved beyond the need for fighting. As the NHL continues to adapt to changing dynamics and priorities, the role of enforcers may continue to evolve. Regardless of the outcome, one thing remains clear: the enforcer will always hold a special place in hockey history, reminding us of a time when toughness and fearlessness were celebrated on the ice.